Share & spread the love

Judicial separation in Family Law is a legal option for married couples who don’t want to completely end their marriage but wish to temporarily suspend certain marital rights and duties. In contrast, divorce brings a complete end to the marriage.

Choosing judicial separation in Family Law offers an alternative to divorce.

Meaning of Judicial Separation

Judicial separation in India is a legal ruling issued by a court that orders a married couple to live separately or stop their marital relations without ending their marriage. It’s sometimes referred to as ‘divorce a mensa et thoro,’ meaning separation from ‘bed and board.’ When a judicial separation is granted, the husband and wife aren’t required to live together or fulfill their usual marital responsibilities. They are essentially living apart by mutual agreement, allowing them time to reflect on their marriage.

This period of separation often leads to either divorce or reconciliation between the spouses, giving them a chance to evaluate their relationship. If they decide they’re not happy in their marriage, they can end it with a divorce agreement.

However, it’s essential to note that during a judicial separation in Family Law, the couple remains legally married and cannot remarry. Marrying someone else during this time could result in charges of bigamy. In the unfortunate event that one spouse passes away while the separation agreement is in effect, the surviving spouse may inherit their property.

For a judicial separation in India to be valid, the marriage itself must be legally valid. Separation agreements typically don’t apply to marriages that are considered void, although there may be exceptions if the marriage is voidable.

What is Judicial Separation in Family Law?

Different personal and family laws govern judicial separation and they are detailed in specific Acts:

  • The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: Applicable to Hindus, including those following Buddhism, Sikhism and Jainism.
  • The Divorce Act, 1869: Pertains to Christians.
  • The Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936: Relates to Parsi individuals.
  • The Special Marriage Act, 1954: Applies to people of all religions and backgrounds.

Hindu Law

In the Hindu law, marriage is considered a sacred sacrament, traditionally believed to be unbreakable and eternal, spanning not only this life but also future ones. Ancient lawgivers like Manu asserted that marriage should be indissoluble. However, with the emergence of new challenges in modern life, Hindu law has evolved. Marriages are no longer viewed as entirely unbreakable and various legal remedies are now available for parties in a marriage in case of disputes or other issues, including divorce and judicial separation.

Section 10 of the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 provides for the legal option of ‘judicial separation,’ and a similar provision is outlined in Section 23 of the Special Marriage Act of 1954. The grounds on which a judicial separation decree can be sought by either the husband or the wife are the same in both of these legislations and are akin to those for divorce.

The various grounds for judicial separation are detailed in Section 13, subsections (1) and (2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and in Section 27, subsections (1) and (2) of the Special Marriage Act, 1954. Under the grounds specified in subsection (1), either party can file a petition for judicial separation, while under the grounds specified in subsection (2), only the wife is allowed to initiate the petition for judicial separation. Some of these grounds include:

Grounds for either party:

  • Adultery
  • Cruelty
  • Desertion
  • Conversion
  • Unsoundness of mind or mental disorder
  • Venereal disease
  • Renunciation
  • Not heard of for seven years
  • Bigamy
  • Husband found guilty of rape, sodomy, or bestiality

Grounds available to the wife:

  • Bigamy
  • Husband found guilty of rape, sodomy, or bestiality
  • Non-resumption of cohabitation after an order of maintenance
  • Repudiation of marriage after the age of 15 and before the age of 18

Muslim Law

In Muslim law, there is no provision for judicial separation. As stated in the case of Rahmat Ullah and Khatoon Nisa v. the State of U.P. (1994), Muslim Personal Law, also known as Shariat Law, recognises the concept of divorce or ‘talaq’ but does not encompass the idea of ‘judicial separation’ found in laws like the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act.

While there’s no specific law allowing for judicial separation in Muslim marriages, there are certain landmark cases that have extended the grounds mentioned in Section 2 of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939, which can lead to the dissolution of a marriage. Some of these grounds include:

  • The husband’s whereabouts being unknown for four years.
  • Neglect or failure to provide maintenance for two years.
  • Husband sentenced to imprisonment for seven years or more.
  • Failure to fulfill marital obligations for three years.
  • Impotency.
  • Insanity or suffering from leprosy or a venereal disease.
  • Repudiation of marriage by the wife before reaching 18 years if the marriage occurred before she turned 15.
  • Cruelty.

In the case of Ms. Jordan Diengdeh v. S.S. Chopra (1985), the judges outlined various grounds under which a Muslim wife can seek a decree for the dissolution of her marriage. This case also emphasised the need for uniform laws regarding the annulment of marriage, divorce and judicial separation that would apply to people of all religions, promoting equality before the law irrespective of one’s religious beliefs.

Christian Law

Christian marriages are celebrated according to Christian customs, ceremonies and traditions in the presence of a religious figure like a minister, clergyman, or other religious leader. These marriages are also treated as contractual agreements.

The legal framework for Christian marriages and other personal matters of the Christian community is primarily governed by the Indian Christian Marriage Act of 1872. However, when it comes to divorce and the dissolution of marriage, the provisions are outlined in the Divorce Act of 1869.

Under Sections 22 and 23 of the Divorce Act, 1869, Christian husbands and wives have the option to obtain a judicial separation decree on grounds such as adultery, cruelty, or desertion lasting over two years. This decree is akin to a ‘divorce a mensa et toro,’ which separates the husband and wife, prohibiting them from living together, but doesn’t dissolve the marriage itself.

This decree can be reversed under Section 26 of the Divorce Act, upon the request of the spouse of the party who initially sought the judicial separation decree. The request can be based on the ground of the absent party’s absence during the judicial separation proceedings. If the court deems this satisfactory, it can issue a decree to reverse the separation.

Parsi Law

In the Parsi religion, marriage is viewed as a contract and is celebrated through a ceremony known as ‘Ashirvad,’ during which a priest bestows blessings upon the married couple in the presence of two Parsi witnesses.

Under the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act of 1936, specific provisions were established to address issues like the annulment of marriage, divorce and judicial separation, aimed at providing relief to married Parsi couples. Section 34 of this act allows for ‘suits for judicial separation,’ which can be initiated by any Parsi husband or wife based on the grounds outlined in the Act for divorce under Section 32. These grounds resemble those found in the Special Marriage Act of 1954 and the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955.

Consequences of Judicial Separation in India

Following a decree of judicial separation in in India, the husband and wife are no longer obliged to live together. While their legal status as a married couple remains unchanged, they are not required to cohabit. Section 376B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, offers legal protection to a separated wife.

It stipulates that if, after a decree of judicial separation, the husband engages in sexual intercourse with her without her consent, he can be held criminally liable. The punishment for such an offense ranges from a minimum of 2 years to a maximum of 7 years in prison. Additionally, spouses are generally prohibited from remarrying during the period of judicial separation.

In the case of Narasimha Reddy v. Basamma (1975), it was determined that if either spouse enters into a new marriage during the period of separation before obtaining a divorce, it constitutes bigamy.

After judicial separation in in India, spouses maintain their property rights as they did before the separation. In the case of Krishna Bhattacharjee v. Sarathi Choudhary (2015), the Supreme Court affirmed the wife’s right to ‘stridhan’ after a separation agreement, considering it her exclusive property.

Sometimes, the court may grant a decree of judicial separation for a one-year period, allowing the spouses to decide between conciliation or divorce. This time provides them with an opportunity to reflect on their marriage and consider reconciliation.

Conclusion

Judicial separation in in India is a legal remedy that allows married couples to live separately and suspend their marital obligations while keeping the marriage legally intact. It does not dissolve the marriage but provides relief from cohabitation and some marital duties. Spouses can seek judicial separation based on specific grounds such as cruelty, adultery, desertion, or mental illness.

During this period, they maintain their legal rights and responsibilities as married individuals, but they do not have to live together. This legal provision can serve as a step toward possible reconciliation or eventually lead to divorce if the marital issues cannot be resolved.


Attention all law students!

Are you tired of missing out on internship, job opportunities and law notes?

Well, fear no more! With 1+ lakhs students already on board, you don't want to be left behind. Be a part of the biggest legal community around!

Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) and get instant notifications.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LawBhoomi
Upgrad