Company Limited by Shares and Company Limited by Guarantee
Companies limited by shares and companies limited by guarantee represent two fundamental models each with its distinct legal, financial and operational characteristics.
This comprehensive exploration delves into the legal frameworks, purposes, advantages and considerations associated with each type of company, offering insights into their relevance and application within the Indian legal context.
Understanding the Legal Foundation
The Companies Act, 2013
The cornerstone of corporate law in India, the Companies Act, 2013, lays down the legal foundation for the establishment, regulation and dissolution of various types of companies. Under this Act, a company is recognised as a separate legal entity, distinct from its members, capable of owning assets, incurring liabilities and entering into contracts.
A company limited by shares is the most prevalent corporate entity in India, designed primarily for profit-making ventures. In this structure, the liability of each member is limited to the amount unpaid on their shares, essentially capping their financial risk to their investment in the company.
- Share Capital: The company issues shares, which represent ownership portions that members or shareholders, can buy.
- Liability: Shareholders’ liability is limited to the value of their shares. If the shares are fully paid, the shareholder has no further financial obligations to the company.
- Governance: Governed by a board of directors elected by shareholders, the company operates to maximise shareholder value, distributing profits as dividends.
Companies Limited by Guarantee
Less common but equally important, companies limited by guarantee are typically formed for non-profit activities, such as clubs, charities and professional associations. Instead of share capital, members agree to contribute a predetermined amount towards the company’s liabilities if it is wound up.
Legal Characteristics of Companies Limited by Guarantee
- Guarantee Amount: Members do not hold shares but instead provide a guarantee of up to a specified amount to cover the company’s debts.
- Liability: Members’ liability is limited to the guarantee amount, which is often nominal.
- Purpose: These companies are usually formed to promote non-profit objectives, with any profits reinvested back into the organisation or used to further its goals.
Companies Limited by Shares and Companies Limited by Guarantee are two distinct legal structures used to form business entities, each with its own unique characteristics, purposes and implications for its members.
Understanding the differences between these two types of companies is crucial for entrepreneurs, founders and those involved in setting up new entities, especially when considering the financial, legal and operational aspects of the business. Here’s a breakdown of the key differences:
1. Definition and Purpose
Company Limited by Shares: This is the most common type of corporate structure, particularly for profit-oriented businesses. In this model, the company’s capital is divided into shares and the liability of each shareholder is limited to the amount unpaid on their shares. It’s designed to operate as a business that seeks to generate profit and distribute dividends to its shareholders.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Unlike the share-based structure, a company limited by guarantee does not have share capital or shareholders. Instead, it has members who agree to contribute a predetermined amount towards the company’s debts in the event of winding up. This structure is typically used for non-profit organisations, clubs and societies where the focus is on providing services or promoting a cause rather than generating profit.
2. Liability
Company Limited by Shares: Shareholders’ liability is limited to the amount if any, unpaid on their shares. This means that if the company faces financial difficulties, the personal assets of the shareholders are protected beyond the amount they have invested in shares.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Members’ liability is limited to the amount they agree to contribute to the company’s liabilities upon winding up, which is usually a nominal amount. This guarantees that members are not heavily financially burdened beyond their commitment.
3. Capital Raising
Company Limited by Shares: Companies limited by shares can raise capital by issuing new shares, offering a flexible way to finance expansion or new projects through equity financing.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Since companies limited by guarantee do not issue shares, they cannot raise capital through equity. Instead, they may rely on membership fees, grants, donations or borrowing.
4. Profit Distribution
Company Limited by Shares: Profit generated by a company limited by shares can be distributed to its shareholders in the form of dividends, proportional to the number of shares each shareholder owns.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Companies limited by guarantee do not distribute profits to their members. Any profits are reinvested back into the company to further its objectives or saved for future use.
5. Governance and Ownership
Company Limited by Shares: Ownership of a company limited by shares is determined by shareholding. The control and decision-making power in the company often correlate with the number of shares owned.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Membership in a company limited by guarantee does not denote ownership in the traditional sense. Control and decision-making are usually outlined in the company’s memorandum and articles of association and all members typically have equal say, regardless of financial contribution.
6. Use Cases
Company Limited by Shares: Ideal for businesses that aim to make a profit and potentially offer returns on investment to its shareholders. This includes startups, SMEs and large corporations.
Company Limited by Guarantee: Suited for non-profit organisations, including charities, clubs and societies, where the goal is to support a cause or provide services without the intention of distributing profits.
7. Legal and Regulatory Requirements
Both types of companies must comply with the legal and regulatory requirements of their jurisdiction, such as the Companies Act in India. However, companies limited by guarantee may be subject to additional regulations if they have charitable status, including specific reporting and operational guidelines.
Here’s a table summarising the key differences between a Company Limited by Shares and a Company Limited by Guarantee:
| Feature | Company Limited by Shares | Company Limited by Guarantee |
| Definition | A legal entity where the company’s capital is divided into shares owned by shareholders. The liability of each shareholder is limited to the amount unpaid on their shares. | A legal entity where members agree to contribute a nominal amount towards the company’s debts in the event of winding up. Does not have share capital. |
| Purpose | Primarily established for profit-making purposes. Aims to generate profits and distribute dividends to shareholders. | Typically established for non-profit purposes, such as clubs, charities and societies. Profits are reinvested to further the organisation’s objectives. |
| Liability | Limited to the amount unpaid on their shares. | Limited to the amount members have agreed to contribute if the company is wound up. |
| Capital Raising | Can issue new shares to raise capital. | Does not issue shares; relies on membership fees, grants, donations or borrowing. |
| Profit Distribution | Profits can be distributed as dividends to shareholders. | Profits are not distributed to members but are reinvested in the company. |
| Governance and Ownership | Ownership is determined by the number of shares held. Control is often related to shareholding percentage. | Members do not own shares. Governance is defined by the memorandum and articles of association, with members usually having equal say. |
| Use Cases | Suited for businesses looking to make a profit and potentially offer returns on investment. | Suited for organisations aiming to support a cause, provide services or promote membership benefits without intending to make a profit. |
| Legal and Regulatory Requirements | Subject to corporate tax on profits, financial reporting and other regulations under corporate laws. | May have additional regulations if classified as a charity, including specific reporting and operational guidelines. |
Attention all law students!
Are you tired of missing out on internship, job opportunities and law notes?
Well, fear no more! With 45,000+ students already on board, you don't want to be left behind. Be a part of the biggest legal community around!
Join our WhatsApp Groups (Click Here) and Telegram Channel (Click Here) and get instant notifications.
