Who Is the Legal Mother of a Child Born Through Surrogacy?

Key Takeaways

• The intended mother is recognised as the legal mother of a child born through a legally compliant surrogacy arrangement in India. Under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, the surrogate mother who carries and delivers the child does not ordinarily acquire legal motherhood merely because she gives birth.
• Section 8 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 determines the legal status of children born through surrogacy. It provides that a child born through surrogacy shall be deemed to be the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman and shall have the rights and privileges of a natural child under the applicable law.
• The surrogate mother and the intending mother have different legal roles. The surrogate mother carries the pregnancy, whereas the intending mother assumes legal parenthood. The distinction is particularly important when questions arise concerning custody, inheritance and parental responsibilities.
• An order concerning parentage and custody is required under Section 4 of the Act. The intending couple or intending woman and the surrogate mother must obtain the prescribed order from a Magistrate of the first class or above before undertaking the surrogacy procedure.
• A woman who donates an egg does not automatically become the legal mother of the child. Genetic contribution and legal parenthood are separate considerations. Where donor gametes are lawfully used, the intending mother remains the legally recognised mother under the statutory framework.
• Children born through surrogacy have legal rights comparable to naturally born children. These include rights concerning parental care, maintenance and inheritance, subject to the applicable legal provisions.
• Surrogacy in India is governed by specific statutory conditions. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022 regulate eligibility, consent, medical procedures, parentage and the protection of children born through surrogacy.

Who Is the Legal Mother of a Child Born Through Surrogacy?

The legal mother of a child born through surrogacy in India is the intending mother, provided the surrogacy arrangement complies with the applicable statutory requirements.

The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 establishes the legal framework for determining parentage in surrogacy arrangements. Section 8 provides that a child born through surrogacy shall be deemed to be the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman.

Add LawBhoomi as your preferred source on Google.

Add Now →

This provision establishes an important distinction between biological childbirth and legal motherhood.

In an ordinary pregnancy, the woman who gives birth is generally recognised as the child’s mother. However, surrogacy involves a different arrangement because the woman carrying the pregnancy is not necessarily the person who intends to raise the child.

Under a legally compliant surrogacy arrangement, the surrogate mother carries and delivers the child for the intending parents or intending woman. The legal relationship between the child and the intending parent or parents is recognised under the Act.

For example, consider a married couple who cannot carry a pregnancy due to a medical condition. They undertake gestational surrogacy through a registered clinic after satisfying the prescribed requirements.

Explore LawBhoomi's free law library for students and lawyers.

Visit Library →

A surrogate mother carries the embryo and gives birth to the child. Although the surrogate mother physically delivers the child, the intending wife is recognised as the child’s legal mother.

Therefore, giving birth through surrogacy does not, by itself, determine legal motherhood under Indian surrogacy law.

What Is Surrogacy Under Indian Law?

Surrogacy is an arrangement in which a woman agrees to carry and give birth to a child for another person or couple, with the intention that the child will be handed over to the intending parent or parents after birth.

Section 2 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 provides the statutory framework for understanding surrogacy and the persons involved in such arrangements.

The Act recognises and regulates gestational surrogacy, subject to specified eligibility and procedural requirements.

Who Is an Intending Mother Under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021?

An intending mother is the woman who seeks to become a parent through a surrogacy arrangement and is recognised as the child’s mother under the applicable legal framework.

The Act uses the terms intending couple and intending woman rather than providing a separate general definition of an intending mother.

Intending Couple

Section 2 defines an intending couple in relation to a married Indian man and woman who satisfy the statutory requirements and seek to become parents through surrogacy.

Explore practical law courses to build career-ready legal skills.

Explore Courses →

Where a married couple undergoes a legally compliant surrogacy procedure, the intending wife is recognised as the mother of the child.

The intending husband is correspondingly recognised as the father under the statutory framework.

Intending Woman

The Act also recognises an intending woman as a separate category.

Under the statutory definition, an intending woman is an Indian woman who is a widow or divorcee and falls within the prescribed age category.

This means that surrogacy is not limited exclusively to married couples. However, eligibility is restricted by the conditions specified under the Act.

An unmarried woman who does not fall within the statutory category of an intending woman cannot automatically claim eligibility to undertake surrogacy merely because she wishes to become a parent.

The distinction is important because the recognition of legal motherhood under Section 8 operates within the statutory scheme governing permitted surrogacy arrangements.

Is the Surrogate Mother the Legal Mother of the Child?

No. In a legally compliant gestational surrogacy arrangement in India, the surrogate mother is not ordinarily recognised as the legal mother of the child.

The surrogate mother is the woman who carries the pregnancy and gives birth to the child on behalf of the intending couple or intending woman.

Discover the latest legal jobs and career openings.

View Jobs →

Her participation is essential to the reproductive process, but her gestational role is legally different from parenthood.

What Does Section 8 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 Provide?

Section 8 is the principal provision governing the status of a child born through surrogacy.

It establishes that a child born through a surrogacy procedure shall be deemed to be the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman.

The provision further recognises that the child is entitled to the rights and privileges available to a natural child under the applicable law.

Legal Recognition of Parentage

Section 8 creates a statutory basis for recognising the child-parent relationship.

Its importance lies in ensuring that the child’s legal status does not remain uncertain merely because a surrogate mother carried the pregnancy.

The provision also reduces the possibility of disputes arising from the distinction between childbirth and legal parenthood.

For example, if a child is born through surrogacy to an eligible intending couple, the law recognises the child as belonging to that couple for purposes of legal parentage.

The surrogate mother’s act of giving birth does not ordinarily displace this statutory recognition.

Equal Legal Status of the Child

Section 8 also protects the legal position of children born through surrogacy.

The child is not to be treated as having an inferior legal status merely because the pregnancy was carried by a surrogate mother.

The legal consequences include recognition of the parent-child relationship for matters governed by applicable family and succession laws.

Importantly, the phrase deemed to be the biological child establishes a legal status. It does not necessarily mean that both intending parents must have contributed their genetic material.

The distinction becomes particularly relevant where donor gametes are lawfully used.

How Is Legal Motherhood Established in Surrogacy?

Legal motherhood in surrogacy is recognised through the statutory framework, supported by the required documentation and parentage order.

Section 4 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 establishes conditions that must be satisfied before a surrogacy procedure can lawfully take place.

Requirement of a Parentage and Custody Order

Section 4(iii)(a)(II) requires an order concerning the parentage and custody of the child to be passed by a Magistrate of the first class or above.

The order is obtained upon an application involving the intending couple or intending woman and the surrogate mother.

The statutory provision also contemplates the prescribed order serving as a birth affidavit after the child’s birth.

This requirement is significant because it provides formal legal recognition and documentation concerning the anticipated parentage and custody of the child.

It also helps establish clarity regarding the responsibilities of the persons participating in the surrogacy arrangement.

Importance of the Parentage Order

The parentage and custody order performs several functions.

• Recognition of the intended parental relationship: It documents the arrangement under which the intending couple or intending woman seeks to assume parenthood of the child.
• Clarity concerning custody: It addresses the intended custody arrangements and reduces uncertainty about who will have parental responsibility after childbirth.
• Protection of the child’s interests: It provides an important legal safeguard within the regulated surrogacy process.
• Documentation of the arrangement: It supports the legal record concerning the persons involved and the parentage contemplated under the Act.

However, the order should not be confused with an adoption order. Surrogacy and adoption are separate legal processes governed by different statutory frameworks.

Can the Surrogate Mother Claim Custody of the Child?

Under a legally compliant surrogacy arrangement, the intending couple or intending woman is recognised as having the parental relationship contemplated by the Act.

The surrogate mother cannot ordinarily claim legal motherhood merely because she carried and delivered the child.

The parentage and custody order required under Section 4, read with the recognition provided under Section 8, establishes the legal framework relevant to such questions.

Nevertheless, custody and guardianship disputes must be distinguished from the general statutory recognition of parenthood.

If a dispute arises because of allegations of fraud, coercion, invalid consent, non-compliance with statutory conditions or other serious circumstances, the matter may require judicial determination.

The legal consequences will depend on the facts, applicable statutory provisions and any relevant court orders.

Therefore, it would be incorrect to suggest that every possible custody dispute involving surrogacy is automatically resolved without judicial examination.

The statutory position is that legal parenthood belongs to the intending parent or parents under a compliant arrangement, while particular disputes may require consideration by the competent court.

What Are the Rights of a Surrogate Mother?

Although the surrogate mother is not ordinarily the child’s legal mother, Indian law recognises important rights intended to protect her during the surrogacy process.

The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 regulates consent, medical eligibility and other conditions associated with surrogacy.

Right to Give Informed Consent

Section 6 requires the surrogate mother’s informed written consent in the prescribed manner.

The surrogate mother must understand the nature of the procedure and the relevant risks before consenting to participate.

Informed consent is particularly important because surrogacy involves medical procedures, pregnancy-related risks and significant personal consequences.

Right to Withdraw Consent Before Embryo Implantation

Section 6 also permits the surrogate mother to withdraw her consent before the implantation of the embryo.

This protection ensures that consent is not treated as irrevocable from the moment the arrangement is proposed.

However, the statutory right of withdrawal under this provision must be understood in relation to the stage of the medical procedure.

It should not be interpreted as an unrestricted right to withdraw from the arrangement at any stage after embryo implantation.

Health and Insurance Protections

The statutory framework requires prescribed safeguards concerning the surrogate mother’s health and insurance.

These requirements are intended to address risks associated with pregnancy and the surrogacy procedure.

The existence of these protections demonstrates that the law distinguishes the surrogate mother’s reproductive role from legal motherhood without disregarding her health, consent and dignity.

Who Is the Legal Mother If a Donor Egg Is Used?

Where a donor egg is lawfully used in a surrogacy arrangement, the intending mother remains the legally recognised mother under Section 8 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.

The use of donor genetic material does not automatically transfer legal parenthood to the egg donor.

However, the use of donor gametes is subject to specific statutory and regulatory restrictions.

Rules Governing Donor Gametes

The Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022, as amended in 2024, permit donor gametes in specified circumstances.

For an intending couple, the amended framework permits the use of a donor gamete where the prescribed medical conditions and certification requirements are satisfied, subject to the applicable restriction requiring at least one gamete from the intending couple.

The regulatory treatment of intending women is separately addressed.

Consequently, donor gametes cannot be used in every surrogacy arrangement merely on the basis of personal preference.

Difference Between Genetic and Legal Motherhood

Consider a situation in which an eligible intending couple requires a donor egg because of a qualifying medical condition.

An embryo is created using the permitted reproductive material and transferred to a surrogate mother.

Three women may have different connections with the child:

• The egg donor provides genetic material and may have a genetic connection with the child.
• The surrogate mother carries the pregnancy and gives birth but does not contribute her own egg.
• The intending mother is recognised as the child’s legal mother under the statutory surrogacy framework.

This illustration shows that genetic contribution, gestation and legal motherhood are distinct concepts.

Does the Legal Mother Need to Be Genetically Related to the Child?

A genetic relationship between the intending mother and child is not an absolute requirement in every legally permitted surrogacy arrangement.

The statutory recognition of parenthood under Section 8 is not identical to a scientific determination of genetic ancestry.

Where donor gametes are used in accordance with the applicable provisions, the legal relationship is determined through the statutory surrogacy framework rather than genetic contribution alone.

However, this does not remove the eligibility restrictions governing surrogacy or the conditions applicable to donor gametes.

The legal distinction is important because the Act recognises parenthood in the context of an authorised reproductive arrangement.

Accordingly, the absence of a direct genetic connection between an intending mother and the child does not necessarily prevent legal motherhood where the arrangement is otherwise permitted by law.

What Are the Inheritance Rights of a Child Born Through Surrogacy?

A child born through a legally compliant surrogacy arrangement is entitled to the legal rights and privileges of a natural child of the intending couple or intending woman.

Section 8 provides the principal statutory foundation for this recognition.

Inheritance and succession rights are therefore determined with reference to the child’s legally recognised parentage and the applicable succession law.

Rights in the Property of the Intending Parents

Where the intending couple or intending woman is legally recognised as the child’s parent, the child may inherit property in accordance with the applicable personal law or statutory succession provisions.

For example, inheritance under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 depends on the applicable rules of succession and the relevant family circumstances.

Similarly, where another personal law or statutory succession framework applies, the child’s entitlement must be assessed under that framework.

Section 8 ensures that birth through surrogacy does not, by itself, place the child in an inferior legal position.

However, it does not create an identical inheritance entitlement in every property or family arrangement regardless of the governing succession law.

Can the Child Inherit from the Surrogate Mother?

The surrogate mother’s gestational role does not ordinarily create a legal parent-child relationship under a compliant surrogacy arrangement.

Consequently, the child does not automatically acquire inheritance rights as the surrogate mother’s child merely because she gave birth.

Any independent entitlement arising from a valid testamentary disposition or another recognised legal basis would have to be considered separately.

Can the Intending Parents Refuse to Accept the Child After Birth?

No. Section 7 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 prohibits the intending couple or intending woman from abandoning a child born through surrogacy on specified grounds.

These include circumstances such as the child’s disability, genetic defect, sex or other medical conditions.

The provision is intended to prevent intending parents from treating the child as someone whose acceptance depends upon particular physical or genetic characteristics.

Difference Between the Intending Mother and Surrogate Mother

The distinction between an intending mother and a surrogate mother is central to understanding legal motherhood in surrogacy.

The comparison establishes that the woman who gives birth and the woman recognised as the legal mother need not be the same person.

Is Surrogacy the Same as Adoption?

Surrogacy and adoption are different legal processes, although both may result in a person becoming the legal parent of a child.

In surrogacy, the child is conceived and born through an assisted reproductive arrangement involving a surrogate mother.

The parentage of the child is governed by the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the applicable rules.

In adoption, an existing child is legally placed with adoptive parents through a process governed by the relevant adoption laws.

Main Legal Differences

Nature of the process: Surrogacy involves reproduction, pregnancy and childbirth through an authorised medical arrangement. Adoption involves the legal establishment of a parent-child relationship with an existing child.

Applicable legal framework: Surrogacy is primarily regulated by the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. Adoption may be governed by the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 other personal laws, depending on the circumstances.

Establishment of parenthood: Surrogacy involves statutory recognition of parentage under Section 8 and the prescribed parentage and custody order. Adoption establishes parenthood through a valid adoption under the applicable law.

Role of the birth mother: In adoption, the child’s birth parentage and the legal consequences of adoption are governed by adoption law. In gestational surrogacy, the surrogate mother carries the pregnancy for the intending parent or parents.

Therefore, a child born through a compliant surrogacy arrangement does not ordinarily need to be adopted by the intending parents merely to establish the parentage recognised under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act.

What Happens If a Surrogacy Arrangement Does Not Comply with the Law?

The legal position becomes more complicated where a surrogacy arrangement violates statutory requirements.

The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 prescribes conditions concerning eligibility, medical procedures, consent, certification and the institutions permitted to conduct surrogacy.

Non-compliance may lead to legal consequences under the Act.

However, determining the child’s parentage in a disputed or unlawful arrangement may require separate legal examination.

Does an Illegal Surrogacy Arrangement Affect the Child’s Rights?

The illegality of a surrogacy arrangement and the legal status of the child are distinct legal questions.

An alleged violation by adults or medical institutions does not, by itself, establish that the child should be deprived of legal protection.

Questions concerning parentage, custody, identity and maintenance may require judicial determination, particularly where the statutory conditions for a compliant arrangement have not been satisfied.

It would therefore be incorrect to assume that Section 8 resolves every dispute concerning an unlawful, informal or irregular surrogacy arrangement without consideration of the facts.

The child’s interests and the applicable legal provisions remain relevant to any judicial determination.

Why Is Legal Motherhood Important in Surrogacy?

Determining legal motherhood is necessary because several legal relationships depend on the identity of a child’s parents.

Uncertainty concerning legal parentage can affect civil status, custody, guardianship, maintenance and inheritance.

Recognition in Birth Records

Legal parentage is important for recording the identity of the child’s parents in official birth documentation.

The required parentage and custody order provides relevant documentation within the surrogacy framework.

Registration and issuance of birth records remain subject to the applicable legal procedures.

Parental Responsibility

Legal motherhood establishes the relationship through which parental rights and responsibilities arise.

These responsibilities include matters relating to the child’s upbringing, care and welfare.

The precise legal duties depend on the applicable family law and the child’s circumstances.

Custody and Guardianship

Recognition of legal parentage provides the basis for identifying the persons responsible for the child’s custody and care.

In India, guardianship matters may also be governed by laws such as the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, where applicable.

This is especially important because the surrogate mother physically delivers the child, while the intending parent or parents are recognised under the surrogacy arrangement.

Maintenance and Financial Support

A legally recognised parental relationship is relevant to determining maintenance and financial responsibilities towards the child.

The relevant obligations must be assessed under the applicable legal provisions.

Succession and Inheritance

Legal motherhood is also important for identifying family relationships relevant to succession.

By recognising the child as a natural child of the intending parent or parents, Section 8 helps ensure that the mode of birth does not become an independent ground for denying the child’s legal status.

Conclusion

The question of who is the legal mother of a child born through surrogacy is determined in India principally by the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.

Under Section 8, a child born through a legally compliant surrogacy procedure is deemed to be the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman. Accordingly, the intending mother is recognised as the legal mother, even though another woman carries the pregnancy and gives birth.

The surrogate mother performs the gestational role but does not ordinarily acquire legal motherhood merely because of childbirth. Similarly, an egg donor does not automatically become the child’s legal mother.

The framework also requires a parentage and custody order, protects the surrogate mother’s informed consent and provides legal recognition to children born through surrogacy.

Ultimately, Indian surrogacy law distinguishes genetic contribution, pregnancy and childbirth from legally recognised parenthood. This distinction is essential for determining parental responsibilities, custody, inheritance and the legal status of children born through surrogacy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Woman Who Gives Birth Always the Legal Mother in India?

No. In a legally compliant gestational surrogacy arrangement, the woman who gives birth is the surrogate mother, while the intending mother is recognised as the legal mother under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.

Can a Surrogate Mother Use Her Own Egg?

No. The statutory framework governing gestational surrogacy does not permit the surrogate mother to provide her own egg for the surrogacy procedure.

Is the Egg Donor the Legal Mother of the Child?

No. Where a donor egg is lawfully used in a surrogacy arrangement, the egg donor does not automatically become the child’s legal mother. Legal parentage is governed by the applicable statutory provisions.

Which Section Recognises the Legal Parents of a Child Born Through Surrogacy?

Section 8 of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 recognises a child born through surrogacy as the biological child of the intending couple or intending woman for legal purposes.

Is a Court Order Necessary for Surrogacy in India?

Yes. Section 4(iii)(a)(II) requires an order concerning parentage and custody from a Magistrate of the first class or above as part of the prescribed requirements for undertaking surrogacy.

Does a Child Born Through Surrogacy Have Inheritance Rights?

Yes. Section 8 recognises the child’s legal status and rights as a natural child of the intending parent or parents. The specific inheritance entitlement is determined under the applicable succession law.