DSA Legal Represents Escorts Kubota in Rs 11.84 Crore Arbitration Award Against Tata AIG

DSA Legal, erstwhile known as Deepak Sabharwal & Associates, represented Escorts Kubota Limited (formerly Escorts Limited) in arbitration proceedings against Tata AIG General Insurance Company Limited, in which the Arbitral Tribunal awarded ₹11.84 crore in claims arising from the repudiation of a Trade Credit Insurance Policy.
The dispute concerned unpaid receivables arising from defaults by Escorts Kubota’s dealers. Tata AIG had repudiated the claims, alleging, among other grounds, that certain invoices reflected bank financing or hypothecation arrangements and therefore did not qualify for insurance coverage.

A key finding of the Tribunal was that endorsements indicating hypothecation or invoice financing on invoices do not, by themselves, establish actual disbursement of funds or disqualify an insurance claim. The Tribunal held that speculative assumptions regarding financing could not override documentary evidence of non-payment. It also recognised balance confirmations and dishonoured cheques as relevant evidence of legally enforceable outstanding debts.
The Tribunal further emphasised that an insurer cannot introduce additional documentary requirements beyond those stipulated in the policy or rely on unsupported Surveyor findings to repudiate claims. The Award reinforces the importance of interpreting insurance contracts in accordance with their express terms and requiring cogent evidence before invoking policy exclusions.
Accordingly, the Tribunal allowed claims aggregating ₹11,84,84,539, along with interest at 9% per annum from the date of the Award and 50% of the Claimant’s arbitration costs.
The Claimant, Escorts Kubota was represented by Deepak Sabharwal, Managing Partner, assisted by Ms. Nandini Garg, Associate, of DSA Legal.




