Difference Between Partnership and Joint Venture

A partnership and a joint venture both involve two or more persons combining resources for a business purpose. However, a partnership is generally created to carry on a continuing business, while a joint venture is usually formed for a specific project, transaction or commercial objective. The main differences relate to duration, scope, mutual agency, legal structure, management, liability and termination.

What Is a Partnership?

A partnership is a legal relationship between persons who agree to carry on a business and share its profits. Section 4 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 defines partnership as the relationship between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all, or by any of them acting for all.

Add LawBhoomi as your preferred source on Google.

Add Now →

The persons who enter into the relationship are individually called partners. They are collectively called a firm, and the name under which the business is conducted is known as the firm name.

A partnership is created by agreement and not merely by status. The agreement may be written, oral or implied from the conduct of the parties. However, a written partnership deed is generally preferred because it clearly records the rights, duties and obligations of the partners.

A partnership may be formed for a fixed period, for a continuing business, at will or for a particular adventure or undertaking. Section 8 of the Indian Partnership Act recognises a particular partnership formed for a specific venture.

What Is a Joint Venture?

A joint venture is a commercial arrangement in which two or more persons or business entities combine their resources, experience or expertise to undertake a particular project, transaction or business activity.

A joint venture is usually created for a specific and limited commercial purpose. For example, two companies may form a joint venture to construct a highway, develop real estate, manufacture a particular product or enter a new market.

Unlike partnership, there is no single general Indian law that governs every type of joint venture. The applicable law depends on the legal structure selected by the parties.

A joint venture may be structured as:

• A contractual arrangement without creating a separate legal entity
• A partnership firm under the Indian Partnership Act, 1932
• A limited liability partnership under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008
• A company incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013

The parties to a joint venture normally agree to contribute money, property, labour, technology, intellectual property, technical knowledge or market access. They also decide how profits, losses, risks, control and management responsibilities will be shared.

Joint control is an important feature of a joint venture. Important commercial decisions are generally taken jointly according to the terms of the joint venture agreement.

A joint venture usually comes to an end when the agreed project is completed, the commercial objective is achieved or the venture is terminated according to the agreement.

Difference Between Partnership and Joint Venture

The difference between partnership and joint venture mainly depends on the purpose, duration and legal relationship between the parties. A partnership normally involves a continuing business relationship, whereas a joint venture is generally restricted to a specific project or transaction.

Mutual agency is essential in a partnership. Every partner may act as an agent of the firm and other partners within the scope of the business. In a joint venture, mutual agency does not automatically arise and depends on the terms of the agreement.

A joint venture may resemble a particular partnership under Section 8 of the Indian Partnership Act. However, every joint venture is not necessarily a partnership. It becomes a partnership only when the essential elements of partnership, particularly mutual agency, are present.

Nature of the Business Relationship

• A partnership is usually formed to carry on a regular and continuing business. The relationship between the partners extends to the entire business of the firm.
• A joint venture is ordinarily formed to carry out a specific transaction, project or commercial activity. The relationship is generally limited to the scope of that venture.

Governing Law

• A partnership is primarily governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932. The rights and duties of partners are determined by the Act and the partnership agreement.
• A joint venture does not have one exclusive governing statute. The Companies Act, 2013, Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008, Indian Contract Act, 1872 or Indian Partnership Act, 1932 may apply depending on its structure.

Duration of the Arrangement

• A partnership may continue for an indefinite period, a fixed term or until it is dissolved according to law. A partnership at will can be dissolved by notice from any partner.
• A joint venture generally continues until the specific purpose is completed. It may also end due to expiry of the agreed period, abandonment of the project or termination under the agreement.

Mutual Agency

• Mutual agency is the true test of partnership. Every partner is both a principal and an agent of the other partners in relation to the business of the firm.
• A joint venturer does not always have authority to bind the other participants. The extent of authority depends on the contractual arrangement between the parties.

Scope of Activities

• A partnership generally covers all business activities carried on by the firm under the partnership agreement. The business may involve several transactions over a long period.
• A joint venture usually has a narrow and clearly defined scope. The participants remain separate and independent in relation to their other businesses.

Legal Structure

• A partnership operates through a partnership firm. Under Indian law, an ordinary partnership firm is not a separate legal entity distinct from its partners.
• A joint venture may operate through a company, LLP, partnership or contractual arrangement. Its legal identity depends on the structure selected.

Sharing of Profits and Losses

• Partners agree to share the profits of the partnership business. The ratio of profit-sharing may be equal or different according to the partnership deed.
• Joint venturers decide how profits, expenses, losses and commercial risks will be distributed. The allocation may depend on capital contribution, responsibility or bargaining power.

Management and Decision-Making

• Every partner ordinarily has a right to participate in the conduct of the partnership business, subject to the terms of the partnership agreement.
• In a joint venture, management powers are specifically divided. Certain participants may control technical operations, while others may handle finance, marketing or administration.

Liability of the Parties

• Partners in an ordinary partnership generally have unlimited liability. They may be personally liable for the debts and obligations of the firm.
• Liability in a joint venture depends on its legal structure. Participants in a company or LLP joint venture may receive limited liability protection.

Ownership of Assets

• Partnership property belongs collectively to the partners and must be used for the purposes of the partnership business.
• Assets used in a joint venture may be jointly owned, separately owned or owned by a company or LLP created for the venture.

Transfer of Interest

• A partner cannot ordinarily introduce a new partner without the consent of all existing partners. Partnership is based on mutual trust and confidence.
• Transfer of interest in a joint venture depends on the agreement and legal structure. Corporate joint ventures may permit the transfer of shares subject to restrictions.

Termination of the Relationship

• A partnership may be dissolved by agreement, notice, expiry of term, completion of business, death, insolvency or other statutory grounds.
• A joint venture normally ends when the project is completed, the purpose becomes impossible, the agreement expires or a termination event occurs.

Is Every Joint Venture a Partnership?

Every joint venture is not a partnership. A joint venture becomes a partnership only when it satisfies the essential requirements of Section 4 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.

The parties must agree to carry on a business, share profits and act for one another. Mutual agency is particularly important. If the participants do not have authority to bind one another, the arrangement may remain a contractual joint venture rather than a partnership.

The description given by the parties is not conclusive. An agreement called a joint venture may legally create a partnership if its actual terms establish mutual agency and a common business. Similarly, an agreement using the word partner may not create a legal partnership if the essential elements are absent.

Particular Partnership and Joint Venture

Section 8 of the Indian Partnership Act allows persons to become partners in a particular adventure or undertaking. A particular partnership may therefore be formed for a single project.

This form of partnership appears similar to a joint venture because both may be limited to one commercial activity. However, a particular partnership remains a partnership and must satisfy all the legal requirements of Section 4.

The existence of a single project does not prevent an arrangement from becoming a partnership. The real question is whether the parties agreed to carry on the venture as principals and agents of one another.

When to Choose a Partnership

A partnership may be suitable where the parties intend to conduct a regular and continuing business together. It is commonly used by professionals, family businesses, small traders and service providers.

A partnership may be preferred when:

• The business is expected to continue beyond a single project.
• The participants intend to actively manage the entire business.
• Mutual agency is acceptable to all parties.
• The business requires a relatively simple organisational structure.
• The participants have a high degree of trust and confidence.
• The rights and duties can be effectively recorded in a partnership deed.

The risk of unlimited liability must be carefully considered before forming an ordinary partnership.

When to Choose a Joint Venture

A joint venture may be suitable where two or more parties wish to collaborate for a defined commercial purpose while continuing their independent businesses.

A joint venture may be preferred when:

• The arrangement relates to a specific project or transaction.
• The parties wish to combine complementary resources or expertise.
• The commercial risk is intended to be shared only for a limited venture.
• Each participant wants to remain independent outside the joint venture.
• The project requires technical knowledge, market access or capital from different participants.
• A company or LLP structure is preferred for limited liability and clearer ownership.

A detailed joint venture agreement is essential to define contributions, control, profit-sharing, liability, intellectual property, dispute resolution and termination.

Conclusion

A partnership and a joint venture both involve cooperation for a business purpose, but their legal nature is different. A partnership usually relates to a continuing business and is based on mutual agency. A joint venture is generally created for a specific project and may take different legal forms. The correct structure depends on the duration, commercial objective, liability, management requirements and intended relationship between the parties.