Mental Health Review Boards under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017

Share & spread the love
Contents hide

Key Takeaways

  • Mental Health Review Boards (MHRBs) are statutory bodies established under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, to protect the rights of persons with mental illness and review certain decisions concerning their admission, treatment and mental healthcare.
  • Sections 73 to 84 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 provide the legal framework for the constitution, composition, powers, functions and procedures of Mental Health Review Boards in India.
  • Mental Health Review Boards consist of six members, including a judicial chairperson, a representative of the district administration, a psychiatrist, a medical practitioner and two representatives from categories connected with mental illness, caregiving or relevant organisations.
  • The major functions of Mental Health Review Boards include dealing with advance directives, appointing nominated representatives, reviewing admission decisions, resolving complaints and protecting the legal rights of persons receiving mental healthcare.
  • Persons with mental illness can approach Mental Health Review Boards to challenge certain admission decisions, seek appropriate remedies and raise complaints regarding violations of their rights. Applications are generally free of charge.
  • Mental Health Review Boards follow specific statutory timelines for deciding applications. Certain urgent matters must be decided within seven days, while other applications may have longer prescribed periods.
  • Decisions of Mental Health Review Boards can be challenged before the High Court under Section 83 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, ordinarily within 30 days.

What Are Mental Health Review Boards?

Mental Health Review Boards are statutory bodies responsible for protecting the rights of persons with mental illness under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

These Boards examine certain decisions relating to psychiatric admission, mental healthcare, advance directives and nominated representatives. They also provide a mechanism through which persons with mental illness can raise complaints and seek remedies when their statutory rights are affected.

LawBhoomi
Add LawBhoomi as your preferred source on Google.
Add Now →

Mental Health Review Boards operate as independent review and adjudicatory bodies within India’s mental healthcare framework.

For example, when a person is admitted to a mental health establishment under the supported admission provisions of the Act, the admission may be challenged before the appropriate Mental Health Review Board.

Similarly, when a person believes that a mental health establishment has failed to provide services required under the Act, the matter may be brought before the Board through the applicable complaint procedure.

The central purpose of these Boards is to ensure that decisions affecting mental healthcare are consistent with legal safeguards, individual rights and the requirements of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

LawBhoomi
Find the latest legal internship opportunities, updated daily.
Find Internships →

Legal Framework Governing Mental Health Review Boards in India

The legal framework governing Mental Health Review Boards is primarily contained in Chapter XI of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

Chapter XI covers Sections 73 to 84 and establishes the organisational and procedural requirements governing the Boards.

The important statutory provisions include:

SectionSubject Matter
Section 73Constitution of Mental Health Review Boards
Section 74Composition of Mental Health Review Boards
Section 75Terms and Conditions of Service of Members
Section 76Decisions of the Board
Section 77Applications to the Board
Section 78Proceedings Before the Board
Section 79Powers and Functions of the Board in Relation to Proceedings
Section 80Time Limits for Disposal of Applications
Section 81Proceedings Before the Board to Be Judicial Proceedings
Section 82Powers and Functions of the Board
Section 83Appeal to the High Court
Section 84Grants by the State Government

Apart from these provisions, the Mental Healthcare (Central Mental Health Authority and Mental Health Review Boards) Rules, 2018, contain procedural and administrative requirements relating to the functioning of the Boards.

Other provisions of the Mental Healthcare Act, particularly those concerning advance directives, nominated representatives, admission and patients’ rights, are also relevant to the exercise of their powers.

How Are Mental Health Review Boards Constituted?

Section 73 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, provides for the constitution of Mental Health Review Boards.

Under this provision, the State Mental Health Authority constitutes the Boards through notification for the areas specified in the notification.

The establishment of Mental Health Review Boards is an important responsibility of the State Mental Health Authority because these bodies provide the statutory mechanism for reviewing matters that directly affect the rights and liberty of persons with mental illness.

LawBhoomi
Discover the latest legal jobs and career openings.
View Jobs →

Role of the State Mental Health Authority

The State Mental Health Authority is responsible for constituting Mental Health Review Boards in accordance with the Act and applicable rules.

The Authority must consider the requirements governing the territorial jurisdiction and functioning of the Boards.

The objective is to establish an accessible mechanism through which individuals can obtain timely decisions concerning mental healthcare.

The number and territorial coverage of Boards are governed by the statutory framework and applicable rules, including amendments made to the 2018 Rules.

Territorial Jurisdiction of Mental Health Review Boards

Each Mental Health Review Board exercises jurisdiction over the geographical area specified for it.

Territorial jurisdiction determines the appropriate Board before which a particular application or complaint may be filed.

This is important because mental health establishments may operate across different districts and regions. Clear jurisdiction helps identify the Board responsible for considering matters arising within a particular area.

The applicable notification constituting the Board and the rules governing territorial coverage must therefore be examined when determining jurisdiction.

Composition of Mental Health Review Boards

Section 74 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, provides that a Mental Health Review Board consists of six members.

LawBhoomi
Find the latest legal internship opportunities, updated daily.
Find Internships →

The composition combines judicial, administrative, medical and community representation.

Judicial Chairperson

The Board is headed by a judicial member who satisfies the qualifications prescribed under the Act.

The chairperson may be a District Judge, a person qualified to be appointed as a District Judge or a retired District Judge.

Judicial representation is significant because the Board deals with matters involving personal liberty, legal rights, procedural fairness and disputes relating to mental healthcare.

Representative of the District Administration

The Board includes a representative of the District Collector, District Magistrate or Deputy Commissioner.

This member provides an administrative perspective and helps connect the functioning of the Board with the district administration.

Administrative representation is particularly relevant where the Board exercises functions concerning institutions, public authorities and the implementation of statutory safeguards.

Psychiatrist

A psychiatrist is included as a member of the Board.

Psychiatric expertise is necessary because several matters before the Board involve clinical questions concerning mental illness, treatment requirements and the circumstances surrounding admission to mental health establishments.

The psychiatrist provides specialised medical knowledge that assists the Board in examining these matters.

Medical Practitioner

The Board also includes a medical practitioner.

This ensures that the decision-making process includes a broader medical perspective, particularly where questions concerning treatment, physical health and clinical procedures arise.

Two Representatives Connected with Mental Healthcare

Two members are drawn from the categories specified in the Act relating to persons with mental illness, caregivers and organisations working in the field of mental health.

Their participation is important because decisions concerning mental healthcare should not be examined solely from legal and medical perspectives.

Representation from these categories helps bring practical experience and the concerns of affected persons into the decision-making process.

Tenure and Appointment of Members

Section 75 regulates the terms and conditions of service of members of Mental Health Review Boards.

Members ordinarily hold office for a term of five years or until attaining the age of 70 years, whichever is earlier.

The Act also permits reappointment, subject to the applicable statutory conditions.

The prescribed framework further deals with matters such as service conditions, resignation and removal.

These requirements are intended to ensure that the Boards have a stable membership structure while maintaining accountability in the performance of their functions.

Powers and Functions of Mental Health Review Boards

Section 82 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, specifies the principal powers and functions of Mental Health Review Boards.

These functions cover several important aspects of mental healthcare and patient protection.

Registration and Review of Advance Directives

An advance directive is a written document through which a person specifies preferences regarding future mental healthcare and treatment in circumstances where the person may subsequently lack the capacity to make relevant mental healthcare decisions.

The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, recognises the right to make advance directives, subject to statutory requirements.

Mental Health Review Boards have functions relating to the registration, review, alteration, modification and cancellation of advance directives.

For example, a dispute may arise where a treating professional considers that following an advance directive would be inconsistent with the patient’s immediate treatment requirements.

In such circumstances, the statutory mechanism permits an application for review in accordance with the Act.

The Board examines the matter and exercises its powers within the limits prescribed by law.

Appointment of Nominated Representatives

A nominated representative is a person recognised under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, to perform specified functions in supporting a person with mental illness.

The role of a nominated representative becomes particularly important where a person requires support in making decisions relating to mental healthcare.

Mental Health Review Boards have the authority to appoint nominated representatives in circumstances specified under the Act.

For example, where the statutory conditions for appointment by the Board are satisfied, the Board may consider an application and determine an appropriate appointment.

The appointment process must respect the rights, wishes and preferences of the person with mental illness, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

Review of Admission Decisions

One of the most significant responsibilities of Mental Health Review Boards is reviewing certain decisions relating to admission to mental health establishments.

The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, establishes safeguards concerning admission and treatment.

Sections 87, 89 and 90 are particularly important in this regard.

The Board may consider applications challenging admission decisions covered by these provisions.

This review mechanism is essential because psychiatric admission may affect personal liberty, movement and the ability to make independent decisions.

The Board examines whether the applicable statutory requirements have been satisfied.

Complaints Regarding Non-Disclosure of Information

Section 25 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, deals with access to basic medical records.

Section 25(3) provides a mechanism for approaching the Board in circumstances involving the withholding of information under the statutory framework.

Mental Health Review Boards may consider applications concerning such decisions.

This function helps balance access to information with the limited grounds on which information may lawfully be withheld.

Complaints Concerning Deficiencies in Mental Healthcare

Section 28 recognises the right to complain about deficiencies in the provision of care, treatment and services.

Mental Health Review Boards have a role in adjudicating complaints under this provision.

Such complaints may concern failures in providing mental healthcare or alleged violations of rights recognised under the Act.

The Board examines the complaint and determines the appropriate response within its statutory powers.

Inspection of Prisons and Jails

Mental Health Review Boards also have powers concerning persons with mental illness in prisons and jails.

These include visiting such institutions and seeking clarification from the medical officer in charge concerning the circumstances covered by the Act.

Such oversight is important because prisoners with mental illness may face particular difficulties in accessing appropriate treatment and legal remedies.

The Board’s statutory functions help ensure that mental healthcare rights remain relevant even where a person is in custody.

Investigation of Violations of Rights

Mental Health Review Boards may investigate matters concerning violations of the rights of persons with mental illness within the scope of their statutory authority.

Where the Act permits, they may take appropriate measures to protect those rights and ensure compliance.

The enforcement framework also provides for penalties in specified cases involving failure to comply with relevant orders or directions.

Such penalties may extend to ₹5 lakh, depending on the applicable statutory provision and circumstances.

Role of Mental Health Review Boards in Psychiatric Admissions

The review of psychiatric admissions is among the most important functions performed by Mental Health Review Boards.

Although the Mental Healthcare Act recognises different forms of admission, not every admission is governed by the same procedural requirements.

Admission of Minors under Section 87

Section 87 regulates the admission of minors to mental health establishments.

It establishes additional safeguards because minors require special protection in decisions concerning psychiatric care.

Applications challenging decisions covered by this provision may be brought before the Mental Health Review Board.

The Board must consider the legal requirements governing admission and the safeguards applicable to minors.

Supported Admission under Section 89

Section 89 governs supported admission for up to 30 days in specified circumstances.

Such admission is permitted only when the statutory conditions are satisfied.

Because supported admission can involve circumstances where a person does not independently consent to admission in the ordinary manner, safeguards are necessary.

Mental Health Review Boards may consider challenges to admission under Section 89 in accordance with the Act.

Supported Admission under Section 90

Section 90 regulates supported admission extending beyond 30 days.

Admissions under this provision involve additional procedural requirements, including oversight by the Mental Health Review Board.

The Board has an important role in determining whether the conditions justifying continued supported admission are satisfied.

Its review helps prevent unnecessary or unlawful continuation of admission.

Who Can Approach a Mental Health Review Board?

Section 77 provides the framework for making applications to Mental Health Review Boards.

Applications may be made by persons with mental illness and other persons authorised under the Act.

The framework includes the following applicants:

  • Persons with mental illness: Individuals may approach the Board regarding matters affecting their rights, admission, treatment or other issues falling within the Board’s statutory jurisdiction.
  • Nominated representatives: Nominated representatives may make applications in circumstances authorised by the Act, particularly where their role involves protecting the interests and exercising relevant rights of the person concerned.
  • Representatives of registered non-governmental organisations: The Act permits representatives of registered NGOs to make applications with the consent of the person with mental illness, subject to the relevant requirements.

Applications to Mental Health Review Boards are free of charge.

This is an important safeguard because access to legal remedies should not depend upon the financial position of the person seeking assistance.

In exceptional circumstances, oral or telephone applications may also be accepted from persons admitted to mental health establishments.

Procedure Followed by Mental Health Review Boards

Sections 77 to 81 contain important procedural provisions governing applications, hearings and decisions.

The procedure is intended to provide an accessible and fair mechanism for resolving matters concerning mental healthcare.

Filing an Application

The process begins when an eligible applicant approaches the appropriate Mental Health Review Board.

The application must relate to a matter falling within the Board’s jurisdiction.

Depending on the nature of the issue, it may concern an advance directive, nominated representative, admission decision or complaint regarding mental healthcare services.

Examination of the Application

The Board considers the application and examines the relevant circumstances.

Where necessary, it may consider medical information, statutory requirements and submissions made by the parties.

The scope of the examination depends on the particular matter before the Board.

Hearing Before the Board

Section 78 governs proceedings before Mental Health Review Boards.

Proceedings are conducted in camera, meaning they are not ordinarily open to the public.

This requirement is important because mental healthcare proceedings frequently involve sensitive medical information and personal circumstances. It also supports the protection of the right to privacy of persons receiving mental healthcare.

The parties may appear personally or through legal counsel or another representative of their choice.

The hearing process must comply with the applicable provisions governing fairness and participation.

Decision of the Board

After examining the matter, the Board makes its decision in accordance with the Act.

Section 76 governs decisions of the Board.

The decision must be communicated in writing within five days after completion of the hearing.

Written communication is important because it provides an official record of the determination and enables affected parties to understand the outcome.

It also assists in exercising the right to appeal where legally available.

Time Limits for Disposal of Applications

Section 80 prescribes time limits for disposing of different categories of applications.

These timelines are particularly important because delays in mental healthcare disputes may affect personal liberty, treatment and access to appropriate services.

Nature of ApplicationPrescribed Time Limit
Appointment of nominated representative under Section 14(4)(d)7 days
Challenge to admission of a minor under Section 877 days
Challenge to supported admission under Section 89(10) or 89(11)7 days
Challenge concerning supported admission under Section 9021 days
Other applications covered by Section 80(4)90 days
Communication of written decision after completion of hearing5 days

The prescribed timelines reflect the importance of resolving urgent matters promptly.

For instance, an application challenging an admission decision may directly concern whether a person should continue to remain in a mental health establishment.

A timely review therefore provides an important protection against prolonged admission without adequate statutory justification.

Are Proceedings Before Mental Health Review Boards Judicial Proceedings?

Yes. Section 81 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, provides that proceedings before Mental Health Review Boards are treated as judicial proceedings for the purposes specified under the Act.

This statutory recognition gives formal legal significance to the proceedings conducted by the Boards.

The provision supports accountability in matters involving evidence, statements and other aspects of the proceedings.

The requirement of a fair hearing is also connected with the principles of natural justice, which promote impartiality and fairness in legal and administrative decision-making.

However, Mental Health Review Boards are specialised statutory bodies rather than ordinary civil or criminal courts.

Their authority is limited to the matters entrusted to them under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

They cannot exercise powers beyond their statutory jurisdiction merely because their proceedings are recognised as judicial proceedings for specified purposes.

Can Decisions of Mental Health Review Boards Be Challenged?

Yes. Section 83 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, provides for an appeal to the High Court against decisions covered by the provision.

An aggrieved person or establishment may challenge the relevant decision before the High Court.

Time Limit for Filing an Appeal

An appeal must ordinarily be filed within 30 days from the date of the relevant decision.

However, the High Court may entertain an appeal after the expiry of this period if sufficient cause for the delay is established.

This allows the appellate court to consider whether the delay should be excused in appropriate circumstances.

Importance of the Right to Appeal

The right to appeal provides an additional legal safeguard against incorrect or unlawful decisions.

A Mental Health Review Board performs important adjudicatory functions, but its decisions remain subject to judicial scrutiny within the framework established by the Act.

High Court oversight helps maintain legal accountability and protects the rights of persons affected by decisions concerning mental healthcare.

Difference Between Mental Health Review Boards and Mental Health Authorities

The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, establishes both Mental Health Authorities and Mental Health Review Boards.

Although they form part of the same statutory framework, their functions are different.

BasisMental Health Review BoardsMental Health Authorities
NatureSpecialised review and adjudicatory bodiesStatutory regulatory authorities
Primary FunctionReview specified decisions and protect individual rightsRegulate and oversee mental healthcare establishments and services
Legal FrameworkPrimarily Chapter XI of the ActProvisions concerning Central and State Mental Health Authorities
Admission DecisionsReview specified admission-related mattersPerform functions assigned under the regulatory framework
ComplaintsAdjudicate complaints within statutory jurisdictionExercise regulatory and other statutory powers
Advance DirectivesPerform registration and review functions under the ActExercise functions assigned to the Authorities
CompositionIncludes judicial, administrative, medical and community representationComposition prescribed separately under the Act
Territorial RoleOperate within notified areasExercise functions at the Central or State level, as applicable

The distinction is important because the State Mental Health Authority constitutes Mental Health Review Boards, but the Boards independently perform the review functions assigned to them by law.

Importance of Mental Health Review Boards in Protecting Patients’ Rights

Mental Health Review Boards play an important role in implementing the rights-based approach adopted by the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

Their significance extends beyond the review of individual medical decisions.

Protection of Personal Liberty

Admission to a mental health establishment may restrict an individual’s freedom of movement.

By reviewing admission decisions covered by the Act, Mental Health Review Boards help prevent unnecessary or unlawful restrictions on personal liberty.

Protection of Autonomy in Mental Healthcare

The Mental Healthcare Act recognises individual participation in decisions concerning mental healthcare.

The provisions relating to advance directives and nominated representatives reflect this approach.

Mental Health Review Boards help implement these provisions by examining disputes and exercising their statutory review powers.

Accountability of Mental Health Establishments

Mental health establishments are required to comply with statutory requirements concerning care, treatment and patients’ rights.

The availability of a complaint and review mechanism strengthens accountability.

Where deficiencies or violations fall within the Board’s jurisdiction, affected persons may seek appropriate remedies.

Access to Legal Remedies

Mental Health Review Boards provide a specialised mechanism for addressing particular mental healthcare disputes.

Free applications, prescribed timelines and provisions for representation improve access to statutory remedies.

The Boards therefore serve as an important connection between mental healthcare administration and legal protection.

Safeguards for Vulnerable Persons

Minors, persons requiring high support and individuals receiving mental healthcare in custodial settings may face additional difficulties in protecting their rights.

The powers of Mental Health Review Boards help address these concerns through review, oversight and other functions prescribed by law.

These safeguards also reflect the broader legal emphasis on protecting the rights of persons with disabilities in India, particularly dignity, autonomy and access to appropriate services.

Challenges in the Functioning of Mental Health Review Boards

Although the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, provides a detailed framework for Mental Health Review Boards, effective implementation depends on several practical factors.

Establishment and Accessibility of Boards

The effectiveness of the statutory framework depends on the constitution and functioning of Boards in accordance with applicable rules.

Where access to a functioning Board is limited, persons seeking review may experience difficulty obtaining timely remedies.

Territorial coverage and administrative arrangements are therefore important for ensuring practical accessibility.

Awareness of Legal Rights

Persons receiving mental healthcare and their families may not always be familiar with the functions of Mental Health Review Boards.

Limited awareness may affect the use of remedies concerning admission decisions, advance directives and complaints.

Clear information about available legal safeguards is necessary for the rights recognised under the Act to be exercised effectively.

Timely Disposal of Applications

The Act prescribes specific timelines for deciding applications.

Meeting these timelines requires adequate administrative support, availability of members and effective procedures.

Delays may be particularly serious in matters concerning continued admission to mental health establishments.

Coordination with Mental Health Establishments

The functioning of Mental Health Review Boards requires interaction with mental health professionals, establishments and other statutory authorities.

Effective coordination is important for obtaining relevant information and implementing lawful decisions.

At the same time, the Boards must exercise their adjudicatory responsibilities independently and in accordance with the Act.

Conclusion

Mental Health Review Boards are an important part of the rights-based mental healthcare system established under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

They provide a statutory mechanism for reviewing admission decisions, considering matters involving advance directives and nominated representatives, addressing complaints and protecting the rights of persons with mental illness.

Sections 73 to 84 establish their constitution, composition, procedures, powers and appellate framework. Their combination of judicial, administrative, medical and community representation enables them to examine mental healthcare disputes from different perspectives.

The effectiveness of Mental Health Review Boards ultimately depends on their proper constitution, accessibility, timely decision-making and consistent implementation of statutory safeguards. By providing independent review of matters affecting mental healthcare, these Boards help strengthen accountability, protect individual autonomy and uphold the legal rights of persons with mental illness in India.

Join LawBhoomi’s 100K+ Community
Aishwarya Agrawal
Aishwarya Agrawal

Aishwarya is a gold medalist from Hidayatullah National Law University (2015-2020). She has worked at prestigious organisations, including Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas and the Office of Kapil Sibal.

Articles: 6609

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *