Is Commercial Surrogacy Legal in India? Laws, Restrictions and Punishment
Commercial surrogacy is illegal in India under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. The law prohibits surrogacy arrangements involving monetary compensation, rewards or financial benefits beyond legally permitted expenses. However, altruistic surrogacy is allowed under specific conditions.
The key legal provisions governing commercial surrogacy in India are:
Add LawBhoomi as your preferred source on Google.
- Commercial surrogacy is prohibited in India. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, which came into force on 25 January 2022, prohibits commercial surrogacy arrangements, including the commercialisation of reproductive services.
- Altruistic surrogacy is legally permitted. Under Section 4 of the Act, surrogacy may be undertaken for specified purposes, subject to eligibility requirements, medical conditions and other statutory restrictions.
- Payment to surrogate mothers is restricted. A surrogate mother cannot receive commercial remuneration or financial rewards. However, prescribed medical expenses, other permitted expenses and insurance coverage are allowed.
- Commercial surrogacy can attract imprisonment and fines. Under Section 38, specified offences relating to commercial surrogacy may attract imprisonment extending to 10 years and a fine extending to ₹10 lakh.
- Intending parents may also face criminal liability. Section 40 prescribes punishment for intending couples, intending women and other persons who seek commercial surrogacy in violation of the Act.
- Surrogacy clinics must comply with statutory requirements. Clinics offering surrogacy-related services must be registered and must follow the standards prescribed under the Act and applicable rules.
- The law aims to prevent exploitation of surrogate mothers. The prohibition seeks to prevent commercial exploitation, unethical reproductive practices and the treatment of surrogacy as a commercial transaction.
Contents
hide
What Is Commercial Surrogacy?
Commercial surrogacy is an arrangement in which a woman agrees to carry and give birth to a child in exchange for money, remuneration, rewards or other financial benefits beyond the expenses permitted by law.
In a surrogacy arrangement, a woman known as the surrogate mother carries a pregnancy with the intention of handing over the child to the intending couple or intending woman after birth, in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.
Commercial surrogacy involves a financial element that goes beyond the reimbursement of permitted expenses. The surrogate mother may receive an agreed amount for carrying the pregnancy, or the arrangement may involve commercial intermediaries who facilitate the process for financial gain.
For example, if a woman agrees to carry a child for an intending couple in exchange for ₹5 lakh as compensation for her services, the arrangement would generally constitute commercial surrogacy under Indian law.
Learn at your own pace with LawBhoomi's recorded law courses.
However, payment of legally permitted medical expenses and insurance coverage does not automatically make an arrangement commercial surrogacy.
Definition of Commercial Surrogacy Under Indian Law
Section 2(1)(g) of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 defines commercial surrogacy.
The definition covers the commercialisation of surrogacy services or procedures, including the sale, purchase or trade of human embryos or gametes and the provision of monetary incentives or rewards to the surrogate mother, her dependants or representatives, except for expenses permitted under the Act.
The definition is broad enough to cover arrangements involving financial benefits that may not be described expressly as payment for surrogacy.
Therefore, the legal nature of a surrogacy arrangement depends on the substance of the financial transaction rather than merely the terminology used in an agreement.
Is Commercial Surrogacy Legal in India?
No, commercial surrogacy is not legal in India. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 prohibits commercial surrogacy and allows only altruistic surrogacy that satisfies the statutory conditions.
Section 3 of the Act prohibits commercial surrogacy-related activities, including the involvement of clinics and medical professionals in prohibited commercial arrangements.
Section 4 establishes the conditions under which surrogacy may legally be undertaken. One of the fundamental requirements is that the procedure must be altruistic rather than commercial.
Find the latest legal internship opportunities, updated daily.
The restrictions apply to commercial surrogacy arrangements within India, irrespective of whether the parties attempt to describe the payment as compensation, a reward or another financial benefit.
Consequently, a private agreement between an intending couple and a surrogate mother cannot legalise an arrangement that violates the Act.
Can a Surrogate Mother Be Paid in India?
A surrogate mother cannot legally receive remuneration merely for carrying a child.
However, the law recognises that pregnancy and childbirth involve medical expenses and certain associated costs. It therefore permits specified expenses and insurance coverage.
The distinction is between:
- Permitted expenses: Medical expenses, prescribed additional expenses and insurance coverage connected with the surrogacy arrangement.
- Prohibited compensation: Payments, monetary incentives, commercial rewards or other benefits provided as consideration for carrying the child beyond what the law permits.
The legality of a payment depends on its nature and whether it falls within the statutory exceptions.
History of Commercial Surrogacy in India
India was previously a prominent destination for international commercial surrogacy arrangements. Fertility clinics offered assisted reproductive services, including surrogacy, to Indian and foreign intending parents.
The relatively lower cost of treatment compared with several other countries contributed to the growth of the surrogacy industry.
However, the expansion of commercial surrogacy also raised legal and ethical concerns.
Access subject-wise law notes for free on LawBhoomi.
Position Before the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021
Before the enactment of comprehensive surrogacy legislation, the legal framework was less developed.
The Indian Council of Medical Research issued guidelines concerning assisted reproductive technology and reproductive clinics. However, these guidelines did not provide the same comprehensive statutory system that was later introduced.
The absence of a detailed legislative framework created concerns regarding the protection of surrogate mothers, the legal status of children, contractual disputes and the conduct of commercial intermediaries.
Questions also arose concerning the extent to which economically disadvantaged women could freely consent to commercial surrogacy arrangements.
Introduction of Statutory Regulation
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 received presidential assent in December 2021 and came into force on 25 January 2022.
The Act introduced a statutory framework governing surrogacy procedures, registration of clinics, eligibility requirements and prohibited practices.
Rather than permitting commercial surrogacy under a licensing system, Parliament adopted a model that prohibits commercial surrogacy while allowing altruistic surrogacy under prescribed conditions.
The legislation operates alongside the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021, which regulates assisted reproductive technology clinics and banks.
Why Is Commercial Surrogacy Banned in India?
The prohibition of commercial surrogacy is intended to address concerns involving exploitation, reproductive health, commercialisation and the legal protection of women and children.
Several considerations influenced the development of India’s surrogacy framework.
Prevention of Financial Exploitation
Commercial surrogacy may involve women who agree to carry pregnancies because of financial difficulties.
Although financial compensation does not necessarily establish exploitation in every arrangement, concerns arise when economic pressure affects the ability to make an independent decision.
The prohibition seeks to prevent circumstances in which economically vulnerable women may be subjected to unfair contractual terms or exploitation by intermediaries.
Protection of Surrogate Mothers
Surrogacy involves medical procedures, pregnancy-related health risks and potential psychological effects.
A legal framework is necessary to ensure informed consent, appropriate medical care and protection against harmful practices.
The Act attempts to protect surrogate mothers by imposing eligibility conditions and restricting commercial arrangements.
Prevention of Commercialisation of Reproduction
Another objective is to prevent reproductive processes from being treated primarily as commercial transactions.
The law seeks to prevent the buying and selling of reproductive services and prohibited trading in embryos or gametes.
This concern also extends to intermediaries or organisations that may profit from prohibited surrogacy arrangements.
Protection of Children Born Through Surrogacy
Surrogacy arrangements may create questions relating to parentage, abandonment and the legal status of children.
The Act addresses these concerns by establishing statutory conditions for surrogacy and recognising the legal status of children born through lawful procedures.
The legislation also prohibits abandonment of a child born through surrogacy on specified grounds, including disability, sex or other circumstances.
Legal Framework Governing Commercial Surrogacy in India
Commercial surrogacy in India is principally regulated by the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 and the Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022, as amended.
The Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 also contains relevant provisions concerning assisted reproductive procedures, clinics and reproductive material.
The development and practical impact of this framework are examined in greater detail in the discussion on the Impact of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021.
Section 3: Prohibition of Commercial Surrogacy
Section 3 establishes several prohibitions concerning surrogacy arrangements.
It restricts clinics, medical practitioners and other persons from undertaking or facilitating prohibited commercial surrogacy activities.
The section also addresses matters such as surrogacy advertisements, exploitation and activities involving prohibited commercial arrangements.
These restrictions are intended to prevent commercial surrogacy from operating through clinics, intermediaries or private contractual arrangements.
Section 4: Regulation of Surrogacy
Section 4 prescribes the conditions under which surrogacy may legally be undertaken.
The Act permits surrogacy only when the statutory requirements are satisfied.
These include conditions concerning:
- Nature of the procedure: Surrogacy must be altruistic and cannot involve prohibited commercial compensation.
- Permitted purpose: The procedure must fall within the purposes recognised under the Act, including specified medical circumstances.
- Eligibility of intending parents: The intending couple or intending woman must satisfy the applicable statutory requirements.
- Eligibility of the surrogate mother: The woman undertaking surrogacy must meet the prescribed age, medical and other conditions.
- Required certificates: The appropriate authority must issue the necessary certificates of essentiality and eligibility, where applicable.
Compliance with these conditions is necessary for a lawful surrogacy arrangement.
Section 38: Prohibition of Commercial Surrogacy and Related Activities
Section 38 addresses serious offences involving commercial surrogacy and other prohibited activities.
These include specified forms of commercial surrogacy, exploitation of surrogate mothers and prohibited dealings involving reproductive material.
The provision establishes substantial criminal penalties for violations falling within its scope.
Section 40: Punishment for Seeking Commercial Surrogacy
Section 40 specifically addresses punishment for seeking commercial surrogacy or failing to comply with the requirements of altruistic surrogacy.
It extends criminal liability beyond clinics and intermediaries to persons who seek prohibited commercial arrangements.
Therefore, intending parents cannot assume that criminal responsibility lies exclusively with a clinic or commercial intermediary.
What Is Altruistic Surrogacy?
Altruistic surrogacy is a surrogacy arrangement in which a woman carries a child without receiving commercial remuneration or financial rewards beyond the expenses permitted under the law.
Section 2(1)(b) of the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 defines altruistic surrogacy.
It excludes charges, expenses, fees, remuneration or monetary incentives of any nature, except the prescribed medical expenses, other specified expenses and insurance coverage.
The essential feature of altruistic surrogacy is that the surrogate mother does not receive payment as compensation for carrying the pregnancy.
However, altruistic surrogacy is not automatically lawful merely because no commercial payment is involved.
The intending parents, surrogate mother, clinic and proposed procedure must satisfy the relevant statutory requirements.
Who Can Opt for Altruistic Surrogacy in India?
The Act recognises specified categories of intending persons who may seek lawful surrogacy.
These include eligible intending couples and eligible intending women, subject to the definitions and requirements prescribed under the Act.
Generally, the statutory framework includes the following conditions:
- An intending Indian married couple must satisfy the applicable marital, age and medical requirements.
- An eligible intending woman is generally an Indian woman who is a widow or divorcee and falls within the prescribed age range.
- The necessary medical indication and other statutory requirements must be established.
- The required certificates must be obtained from the competent authority.
The Act generally specifies an age range of 23 to 50 years for an intending wife and 26 to 55 years for an intending husband, while the prescribed age range for an eligible intending woman is 35 to 45 years.
Eligibility must also be considered in light of applicable rules and relevant judicial orders.
Difference Between Commercial and Altruistic Surrogacy
The principal difference between commercial and altruistic surrogacy is the payment or financial benefit received by the surrogate mother.
Commercial surrogacy involves prohibited financial compensation, whereas altruistic surrogacy excludes commercial remuneration.
| Basis | Commercial Surrogacy | Altruistic Surrogacy |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Surrogacy involving commercial compensation or financial rewards | Surrogacy without prohibited commercial remuneration |
| Legal Status | Prohibited in India | Permitted subject to statutory conditions |
| Payment | Involves payment beyond legally permitted expenses | Limited to legally permitted expenses and insurance |
| Financial Benefit | Surrogate mother may receive compensation for carrying the child | No commercial reward for carrying the child |
| Intermediaries | Commercial brokerage and prohibited arrangements are restricted | Must comply with non-commercial statutory requirements |
| Legal Framework | Prohibited under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 | Regulated under the same Act and applicable rules |
| Criminal Liability | May attract imprisonment and fines | Lawful when all statutory requirements are satisfied |
Both arrangements may involve assisted reproductive technology and medical procedures.
However, the presence or absence of commercial compensation creates a fundamental legal distinction.
What Expenses Are Allowed in Altruistic Surrogacy?
Indian law permits certain payments associated with a lawful surrogacy arrangement.
The purpose is to ensure that the surrogate mother receives appropriate medical care and insurance protection without converting the arrangement into a commercial transaction.
Medical Expenses
Medical expenses connected with the surrogacy procedure are permitted within the statutory framework.
These may involve fertility treatment, pregnancy-related medical care, investigations, hospitalisation and childbirth-related treatment, depending on the applicable requirements.
The permitted expenses must remain within the scope recognised by law.
Insurance Coverage
The law requires insurance coverage for the surrogate mother in accordance with the applicable statutory provisions and rules.
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Rules, 2022 prescribe insurance coverage for a period of 36 months in connection with the surrogacy arrangement, subject to the applicable conditions.
This requirement is intended to provide financial protection against specified health complications arising from the pregnancy and related procedures.
Other Prescribed Expenses
Other expenses may be permitted where expressly recognised by the Act and rules.
However, payments cannot be treated as lawful merely because the parties describe them as gifts, allowances or reimbursement.
The actual purpose of a payment is relevant in determining whether it constitutes prohibited commercial remuneration.
Punishment for Commercial Surrogacy in India
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 provides criminal penalties for commercial surrogacy and related violations.
The penalties differ according to the nature of the offence and the persons involved.
Punishment Under Section 38
Section 38 prescribes punishment for specified offences involving commercial surrogacy and related prohibited activities.
The punishment may extend to:
- Imprisonment: Up to 10 years.
- Fine: Up to ₹10 lakh.
The provision applies to specified serious violations, including prohibited commercial activities and exploitation associated with surrogacy.
Punishment Under Section 40
Section 40 addresses persons seeking commercial surrogacy or violating the conditions governing altruistic surrogacy.
The punishment is generally as follows:
| Nature of Offence | Imprisonment | Fine |
|---|---|---|
| First offence | Up to 5 years | Up to ₹5 lakh |
| Subsequent offence | Up to 10 years | Up to ₹10 lakh |
The penalties demonstrate that the prohibition applies not only to providers of surrogacy services but also to persons seeking arrangements that violate the Act.
The exact criminal liability depends on the applicable statutory provision and the facts of the case.
Rights of Surrogate Mothers in India
The legal framework provides several protections intended to safeguard surrogate mothers during lawful surrogacy arrangements.
Right to Informed Consent
A surrogate mother must provide informed consent in accordance with the statutory requirements.
Consent is important because surrogacy involves medical intervention, pregnancy and potential health risks.
The consent process must comply with the requirements prescribed under the Act and rules.
Right to Insurance Coverage
Insurance coverage is an important statutory safeguard.
The intending couple or intending woman must comply with the prescribed insurance obligations to provide protection against specified medical risks and complications.
Right to Withdraw Consent Before Embryo Implantation
The Act recognises the surrogate mother’s right to withdraw her consent for surrogacy before the implantation of the embryo in her womb.
This protection is intended to preserve reproductive autonomy during the period before implantation.
Protection Against Exploitation
The Act prohibits specified exploitative practices, including commercial exploitation associated with surrogacy.
It also establishes restrictions intended to protect surrogate mothers from being subjected to unlawful reproductive arrangements.
Protection Against Forced Abortion
The Act imposes restrictions concerning abortion during surrogacy and requires compliance with the applicable legal framework.
The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971 remains relevant to the lawful termination of pregnancies.
Surrogacy arrangements cannot override the statutory requirements governing medical termination of pregnancy.
Can Foreigners Opt for Commercial Surrogacy in India?
No, foreigners cannot legally enter into commercial surrogacy arrangements in India.
The prohibition of commercial surrogacy applies irrespective of whether the intending parents are Indian nationals or foreign nationals.
Foreign nationals cannot bypass the prohibition by engaging a private clinic, intermediary or surrogate mother.
The eligibility framework for lawful surrogacy is also restrictive and does not provide a general entitlement for foreign nationals to obtain surrogacy services in India.
The citizenship and eligibility requirements must be considered separately from the general prohibition of commercial compensation.
Is Commercial Surrogacy Legal Through Private Agreements?
A private agreement cannot make commercial surrogacy lawful in India.
For example, an intending couple and a surrogate mother may voluntarily sign an agreement providing financial compensation for carrying a child.
However, contractual consent does not override a statutory prohibition.
Under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the consideration or object of an agreement is unlawful if it is forbidden by law or would defeat the provisions of any law.
Consequently, an agreement whose object involves prohibited commercial surrogacy cannot be treated as an enforceable arrangement merely because the parties voluntarily accepted its terms.
The legal consequences of a particular agreement would depend on its terms, surrounding circumstances and applicable statutory provisions.
Challenges and Criticism of the Commercial Surrogacy Ban
The prohibition of commercial surrogacy has generated debate concerning women’s autonomy, reproductive rights and the effectiveness of the regulatory framework.
Reproductive Autonomy
One criticism concerns the extent to which the State should restrict a woman’s decision to become a surrogate mother in exchange for financial compensation.
Supporters of greater reproductive autonomy argue that informed consent and adequate legal safeguards may provide an alternative to a complete prohibition.
The legislative approach, however, places greater emphasis on preventing exploitation through the prohibition of commercial arrangements.
The broader constitutional discussion on autonomy is connected with Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which protects life and personal liberty.
Economic Concerns
Commercial surrogacy previously provided a potential source of income for some women.
Critics argue that prohibition may remove an economic opportunity without necessarily addressing the underlying financial inequalities that influence such decisions.
Conversely, supporters of the ban argue that economic vulnerability can undermine genuinely voluntary participation.
Possibility of Unregulated Arrangements
Another concern is that strict prohibition may encourage some surrogacy arrangements to operate outside the formal regulatory system.
Unregulated arrangements may create risks involving medical safety, financial exploitation and legal uncertainty.
Effective implementation therefore requires monitoring of clinics and action against prohibited commercial practices.
Limited Access to Surrogacy
The eligibility requirements for altruistic surrogacy restrict access to specified categories of intending persons.
These restrictions have generated debate about reproductive choice, equality and the appropriate extent of legislative control.
The constitutional and policy questions concerning eligibility are distinct from the question of whether commercial surrogacy is permitted.
Conclusion
Commercial surrogacy is illegal in India under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021. The legislation prohibits financial compensation, monetary incentives and commercial rewards connected with surrogacy beyond legally permitted expenses.
India follows an altruistic surrogacy model, under which a surrogate mother may carry a child without receiving commercial remuneration. Medical expenses, prescribed additional expenses and insurance coverage are permitted, provided the statutory requirements are satisfied.
The law also establishes eligibility conditions, registration requirements and criminal penalties to prevent commercial exploitation and unlawful reproductive arrangements.
Although the prohibition seeks to protect surrogate mothers and children, it continues to raise questions concerning reproductive autonomy, economic vulnerability and access to assisted reproductive services.
The legal position remains that commercial surrogacy is prohibited in India, while altruistic surrogacy is permitted only within the framework established by law.
Join LawBhoomi’s 100K+ Community
